Allandale Station Lands
Nestled on the south-eastern edge of the City of Barrie overlooking Kempenfelt Bay, the Allandale Train Station was the hub of activity in the early 1900’s for the Grand Trunk Railway (GTR). The Allandale Train Station was designated under the Federal Heritage Railway Stations Act, which is administered by the Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada.
Posted August 18, 2017
The City of Barrie continues to follow the archaeological processes, applicable legislation and any direction provided by the Province of Ontario to ensure protection of the archaeological potential of the site. The City remains committed to engaging with the appropriate First Nations parties throughout this process.
In late 2016, an RFP was issued by the City of Barrie to retain an independent archaeologist to conduct a new study, separate from any previous study on this site. This RFP was issued in collaboration with the Huron-Wendat and Williams Treaty First Nations.
In January 2017, the City awarded the contract to AECOM to complete a full archaeology assessment of the Allandale Train Station site, including stage 1, 2 and 3 studies. Pending results of the studies, a stage 4 assessment will be conducted.
The stage 1 assessment has been received by the City in draft form and is under review. The stage 2 assessment started in the beginning of May. This stage includes hand digging 275 test pits on the site. Through this stage, the archaeologist identified focus areas to continue into the stage 3 assessment. The stage 3 assessment has been completed and the City is awaiting the report.
A representative from both Huron-Wendat and Williams Treaty First Nations were invited to monitor each stage of the site excavation. In addition, the City of Barrie retained Dr. Gary Warrick as an independent consultant to conduct a peer review of the archeology results and findings.
The City of Barrie has followed all standards and guidelines on archaeology investigations and consulted the Registrar of Cemeteries, Ontario Heritage Trust and the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism.
No work will happen on the site until all archaeology work is complete. If anything of historical significance is found, the City will consult with all applicable First Nations to determine an appropriate path forward.
Nestled on the south-eastern edge of the City of Barrie overlooking Kempenfelt Bay, the Allandale Train Station was the hub of activity in the early 1900’s for the Grand Trunk Railway (GTR). The station buildings consisted of a passenger depot and restaurant as well as a two storey office building. Three years after the bankruptcy of the GTR in 1919, the Allandale Train Station came under the jurisdiction of the Canadian National Railway (CNR). Following years of declining passenger and freight traffic, Allandale was downgraded from a divisional point to a station in 1959. Due to the diminishing rail service, the passenger depot and restaurant were closed during the 1980’s. VIA Rail and GO Transit last used the office building as a passenger waiting room and for ticket sales briefly in the early 1990’s.
The Allandale Train Station was designated under the Federal Heritage Railway Stations Act, which is administered by the Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada. Restoration of the Allandale Train Station is under the guidance of the Ontario Heritage Trust. The heritage value of the Allandale Train Station resides in its picturesque massing, the composition of its elevations, its residential scale, Italianate Villa detailing and its visual as well as symbolic identity with the community. The characteristic picturesque elements of the turn-of-the-century railway stations include the wide overhanging eaves, covered outdoor waiting areas, dominating rooflines and a non-frontal asymmetrical composition. The massing of this mid-size station consists of three functionally separate elements; the office building, restaurant building and passenger depot; and the overall composition of a residential scale. Visual unity of the parts is achieved by the strong horizontal lines created by the dominant rooflines, the brick plinth, repetitive columns, horizontal windows and transom bars and the narrow horizontal wood siding and wood details such as the stringcourse. The Ontario Heritage Trust recommended that the target date of restoration be 1904 – 1905 for the passenger depot and the restaurant building; and 1895 for the office building.
Scope of work completed
Base Building Restoration (Phases 1 and 2A)
Phase 1 and 2A provided the necessary scope and resources to save the buildings to ensure that present and future members of the public can enjoy these buildings for generations to come. The buildings were deteriorating as major problems continued to worsen including roof, structural and wooden heritage features, etc. Further delaying the work would have escalated restoration costs and some heritage features would have been permanently lost. Phases 1 and 2A are described in detail below.
Phase 1 is complete and included minor maintenance works and the completion of the Detail Design which specifically included:
i. Completion of minor works in preparation of the major tender;
ii. Repair of major leak in roof;
iii. Removal of asbestos;
iv. Removal of fire damage in the wood attic using specialized Dry Ice techniques;
v. Clean-up of site;
vi. Salvage historical elements;
vii. Inventory of historical elements;
viii. Investigations into the original materials and finishes (e.g. paints, stains, etc.);
ix. Improvements to security and safety of the site;
x. Investigation of building structural rehabilitation requirements;
xi. Investigation of foundation reinforcing measures;
xii. Investigation of measures to permanently address building settlement areas;
xiii. Preparation of energy/water reduction reports (LEED assessment);
xiv. Issuance of Contractor Pre-qualification Documents; and
xv. Preparation of tender documents and Architectural/Engineering drawings.
Phase 2A is the Base Building Restoration and complete. This ensured the long term preservation of the Allandale Train Station which included:
i. Reinforcement of foundations;
ii. Reinforcement of structural walls;
iii. Replacement of roof shingles;
iv. Reinforcement of attic support for ventilation units;
v. Replication of the tower on the southerly building;
vi. Restoration of exterior walls;
vii. Restoration of the two breezeways;
viii. Restoration of ceilings;
ix. Partial restoration of the interior walls to include insulation and vapour barrier;
x. Repair/replacement of sub-floors as needed;
xi. Reinstallation of salvaged historical elements, including replicas where necessary;
xii. Upgrades to meet the latest Building Code;
xiii. Upgrades to meet the Accessibility For Ontarians with Disabilities Act;
xiv. Partial Installation of base Mechanical and Electrical systems, including access; and
xv. Installation of main site services including Natural Gas, Hydro, Telephone, Cable, etc.